As a bartender, I’ve had the pleasure of watching the world of mixology evolve over the years. Amidst all the trends and fleeting fads, one spirit has remained a timeless favorite: coconut rum, specifically Captain Morgan’s iconic take on this tropical treasure. Its signature smoothness and sweet undertones have captivated palates far and wide.
As someone who’s spent countless hours behind the bar, I’ve had the privilege of refining my craft by experimenting with innovative recipes that bring out the best in Captain Morgan Coconut Rum. Now, I’m thrilled to share my top picks for the most scrumptious and refreshing cocktails that showcase this beloved spirit. Whether you’re seeking a revitalizing summer sipper or a warm, cozy wintertime treat, I’ve got the perfect concoction for you.
From timeless classics to creative twists, these recipes are sure to delight even the most discerning cocktail enthusiasts. So grab a bottle of Captain Morgan Coconut Rum and let’s get shaking (and stirring)!
Captain & Loco
Captain & Loco is a mouthwatering blend of Caribbean rum, aromatic spices, and genuine coconut liqueur that embodies the essence of summer. This indulgent shot offers an unparalleled experience for those who crave the rich flavor of coconut and seek to unwind with a refreshing beverage. Served chilled or as part of a creative cocktail recipe, Captain & Loco is an absolute must-try for anyone yearning for a tropical escape.
By embracing the laid-back vibes of this delightful coconut cocktail, you’ll be transported to a paradise where worries fade away and the good times roll.
Spiced Coconut Rum Shakes
Imagine sipping on a decadent treat that combines the richness of coconut sorbet and vanilla ice cream with the bold warmth of spiced rum. The Spiced Coconut Rum Shake is more than just a drink – it’s an experience. When you blend together these creamy ingredients, you get a smooth, indulgent concoction that’s sure to satisfy any sweet tooth. To take it to the next level, top it off with a dollop of whipped cream and a sprinkle of freshly grated nutmeg.
The result is a visually stunning drink that’s perfect for winter gatherings or any occasion where you want to impress your guests. As the flavors meld together, the spiced rum adds a cozy touch, making this cocktail a great choice for snuggling up by the fire with friends and family.
Bahama Mama
Imagine sipping on a tropical getaway, without ever leaving your home. The Bahama Mama cocktail is a sweet and refreshing concoction that’s perfect for any occasion. With Captain Morgan Coconut Rum as its star ingredient, pineapple and orange juice adding a touch of citrus, this drink is a true taste of the Caribbean. While coconut enthusiasts will delight in the prominent flavor, those who aren’t fans can simply substitute it with white rum to create a new twist.
This popular cocktail, named after a Bahamian dancer, has been transporting people to island vibes for years. Whether you’re looking to escape reality or simply enjoy a tasty treat, the Bahama Mama is an excellent choice. Its laid-back charm and easy-to-make recipe make it a great option for anyone seeking a little tropical fun.
Tipsy Mermaid Rum Punch
The Tipsy Mermaid Rum Punch is an alluring and revitalizing cocktail that combines the richness of multiple types of rum with the sweetness of pineapple juice and the vibrant hue of Blue Curacao. Its versatility is further highlighted by the option to substitute lemonade for pineapple juice, adding a tangy twist to this tropical treat.
This show-stopping drink is perfect for social gatherings or cozy nights in, guaranteed to delight your guests with its breathtaking appearance and delectable flavor profile.
Loco Unicorn
Looking to shake things up with a show-stopping cocktail that’s as delightful as it is delicious? The Loco Unicorn is just the ticket! This vibrant, rainbow-hued drink boasts a purple edible glitter rim, making it an undeniable conversation starter. But don’t let its dazzling appearance fool you – this sweet and creamy concoction packs a flavor punch with Captain Morgan’s LocoNut coconut liqueur, berry-flavored grenadine, orange-flavored blue curacao, and coconut water.
With its tropical blend of fruity flavors, the Loco Unicorn is an ideal choice for sipping on a warm day or enjoying in moderation at your next gathering. And the best part? Its liqueur-based formula makes it easy to pace yourself and enjoy the fun without getting overwhelmed.
Coconut Pineapple Martini
Sipping on a Coconut Pineapple Martini is a quintessential summer experience. This refreshing cocktail offers a lighter take on the classic Pina Colada, with a sharp and vibrant taste that’s perfect for hot days. The combination of coconut rum, pineapple juice, and other ingredients creates a one-of-a-kind flavor profile. What’s more, there are two variations of this recipe to try, each offering its own unique twist.
The first rendition incorporates Disaronno amaretto, lending a bright and zesty quality to the drink. In contrast, the second variation employs fresh-squeezed lime juice and small-batch grenadine, amplifying the overall flavor experience. If you’re seeking a cocktail that’s both easy to make and impossible to resist, look no further than the Coconut Pineapple Martini – it’s a must-try for any discerning drink enthusiast.
Mermaid Water
Sip into summer with the refreshing ‘Mermaid Water’ cocktail, a tropical treat that combines the zesty zip of limeade, sweet notes of pineapple juice, and spicy kick of ginger ale with a trio of rums – Captain Morgan Spiced Rum, Malibu Rum, and Blue Curacao. The vibrant green hue adds to its laid-back charm, making it an ideal addition to any poolside or beach bash. For those who crave fruity and sweet drinks with a hint of adventure, ‘Mermaid Water’ is sure to delight.
Give it a try and let the flavorful escape whisk you away to a tropical haven.
Pina Colada
The Pina Colada has been a beloved tropical cocktail for decades, its allure only enhanced by the combination of pineapple juice, coconut cream, and rum. As a sweet and refreshing drink, it’s an ideal companion for hot summer days spent lounging by the pool or hosting a lively gathering. The introduction of Captain Morgan Coconut Rum takes this classic cocktail to new heights, introducing a subtle yet delicious hint of coconut flavor that beautifully harmonizes with its other ingredients.
Whether you’re seeking a tropical escape or simply looking to elevate your cocktail game, the Pina Colada is an absolute must-try, transporting you instantly to a state of island bliss.

I’m Brandon, the face behind the recipes. As a dedicated food enthusiast, I love experimenting with flavors and sharing my culinary adventures with you.